Contact Info: Kensington PalmInfoCenter.com Bottom Line: The Price:
The Cons:
PalmInfoCenter.com Ratings*:
*Maximum Rating is FIVE (5) InfoPalms |
PDA Protector Review By Ed Hardy 10/8/2001 The Kensington PDA Protector is an aluminum hardcase. There is a version for the Palm m500 series and V series, and another that fits most Visor models. It offers a different design from most hard cases. Instead of opening to the left like a book, it opens upwards. This means it works as well for left-handed people as right-handed. The top doesn't fold around all the way to the back. It does open more than 180 degrees, wide enough that you can lay the case completely flat on a table or desk. The case itself is shaped to hold the handheld in. The back plate bends up to form the sides and even continues slightly onto the front, forming a sort-of cradle for the palmtop. You put the handheld in by opening the case as wide as possible and sliding it in from the top, under the two side holders. The entire interior of the PDA Protector is covered with some kind of artificial velvet-type stuff. This means you don't scratch up the finish on your handheld by rubbing metal against metal. I was only able to test this with an m505 and it fit perfectly. I heard from someone who tried one of these with his m500 and thought it was too loose because that model is a bit thinner than the m505. The top is held closed with a couple of small magnets. This seems quite secure and I prefer this to Velcro because magnets don't wear out. The handheld is completely usable while still in its case. The cover, when flipped open, makes it a bit top heavy when held but I don't think that's a big deal. The stylus is easily accessible. The infrared port can still be used; the front cover even forms a nice resting place to put the second handheld. I found I needed to slide the handheld up a bit in the case to get at the SD slot. However, because the serial port is blocked, you have to take the case out to put the handheld into its cradle. If you really want to you can avoid this by HotSyncing via infrared but there is no other alternative for charging the battery. Still, since taking the palmtop out of the case is so easy, it's not a big deal. However, I am a bit concerned that sliding the handheld in and out of the case every day will eventually wear down the interior lining until the aluminum is rubbing on the handheld's body. This isn't even close to happening with my demo model but it is a possibility in the future. The PDA Protector is a darn good-looking case. It looks very professional, closed or open. The m500/V series model comes in either Platinum or Blue Ice. Translated, that means dark gray or blue. The Visor version is Graphite, read black. These are just highlight colors, being used only on the back, sides, and the small part of the sides that extends onto the front. The front cover is light gray for all models. It feels as good as it looks. The aluminium has been rubberized so it isn't too slick and feels very comfortable in the hand. The coating also means it won't slide off your desk as easily, too. Like any case, the PDA Protector adds a slight bit of bulk to the handheld. It is 4.75 by 3.4 by .6 inches, while the m505 is 4.5 by 3.1 by .5 inches. I think this is close to being as small as a case can be and provide any kind of protection. It is roughly as thick as the m505 with the leather flip cover that comes with it. Naturally, the Visor version is larger. This case seems reasonably rigid and I can see it protecting your palmtop if someone sat or even stepped on it. I have no idea if it would be enough to save your handheld if you dropped it down the stairs. If anyone would like to contribute a working m505 for this test, please let me know. I'm not going to try it with my own. At least not deliberately. At this time, its not available anywhere online that I could find. Even Kensington doesn't have any in stock. They do list a group of webstores but I got exasperated with searching through all the sites before I found even one that was selling it online. So far, the only people I've heard of who have these have found them in electronics stores. If you want one, you'll probably have to call around in your area looking for it. At $30, the PDA Protector is much less expensive than its rivals and its stylish exterior will appeal to almost everyone. No two ways about it, this is really an excellent case.
A Lost Cause Also on the label is a phone number and website that the person who finds the item can use to get into contact with StuffBak. They then contact you and send you your property back. It doesn't cost anything unless you actually get an item returned. StuffBak then charges you $15 plus shipping charges, if any. I'm in favor of any service that can help people get their lost valuables returned, especially if it only costs anything if you actually use it. |
Article Comments
(50 comments)
The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PalmInfocenter is not responsible for them in any way.
Please Login or register here to add your comments.
Comments Closed
This article is no longer accepting new comments.
RE: Ed Can you put a photo of a palm inside the case.
Why is that link missing from the review???
RE: Ed Can you put a photo of a palm inside the case.
Sorry, I can't take a picture of my m505 in the case because I'm taking the picture with a PalmPix and the m505. Kensington has this picture.:
http://www.buykensington.com/buykensington_assets/product_images/1829305.jpg
I didn't include a link to the larger version of the second picture because I think the picture is just awful. It actually looks better in the small version.
---
News Editor
How this case compares to Rhinoskin and Ibiz?
I have heard lots of problems with the Rhinoskin including the razor sharp edges that can scratch the Palm. Also i heard that Rhinoskin's mounting system damages the stylus slot. And the Ibiz I have not hear a review.
Can someone compare these 3 cases. Thanks
RE: How this case compares to Rhinoskin and Ibiz?
1. Sharp edges. The fit is not 100% perfect, and the m505 slips up and down the side rail a few millimeters. If you shut the case without looking, you could scratch the side of your palm.
2. Slide rail is metallic, and not a 100% match for the m505 or m500. It fits, as designed, down the side of the rail. But it does not click or hold the palm in place. If you open your palm, and tip the case, the palm will slide out before you know it.
3. The Rhinoskin hard case, when lined up next to the slider, is the same size (eyeball'ed.) It is still not the sleek small size that the original Palm hard case was for the V and Vx.
4. The Kensignton case is only $30. It is very snug, excellent quality, completely metal, the same dimentional size (eyeball'ed) as the Rhinoskin.
RE: How this case compares to Rhinoskin and Ibiz?
So the Molded Rinoskin case that opens like a clam (not the slider) is the one you took back? But the kensington that is essentialy the same was OK and you kept it? (I might just get this reviewed case or the kensington then.)
I gave my rinoskin slider away, it was too big and too sharp edged for my needs.
I have a scribble pda case for my 505 and it is completely indestructable but there is a size penalty I am not 100% happy with.
Would you say that the kensington is comparable in size to the old plasti-aluminum thing that palm used to make for the Vx?
RE: How this case compares to Rhinoskin and Ibiz?
It was sharp on the edges, tinny in feel, (looked good)
and it is made for the Palm V or the M500 series so the size is not a glove fit.
I also tried the one from Franklin Covey, it's ok but a little too much plastic (not like the sleek one that Palm made at first). I have ordered the one from overseas and I hope I will like that one. I will try this one from Kensington too!
Greetings! morningstar1844@hotmail.com
RE: How this case compares to Rhinoskin and Ibiz?
I also owned a Rhinoskin case for a Vx. It was also extremely tight in the way the rail fit. So much so, that after a time, the Vx's rail would no longer securely hold the Vx supplied leather cover. I'm hoping the the m505's rails are stronger...
RE: How this case compares to Rhinoskin and Ibiz?
Found Mine at Best Buy
A Palm in hand is worth two in your pocket.
RE: Found Mine at Best Buy
A Palm in hand is worth two pocket pc's?
RE: Found Mine at Best Buy
A Palm in hand is worth two pocket pc's?"
Well.. it would take at least two pocket pc's to do what I do on one Palm :)
A Palm in hand is worth two in your pocket.
Too big for m500
For the (?few) of us who own m500's, this case is ill-fitting. My palm literally could slide out of the case after a few days
of taking it out of the case to synch. Guess I'll keep looking. Sigh...
RE: Too big for m500
I picked up a pack of Velcro at a craft store, cut a 1/2" by 1 3/4" piece of the "loop" (cloth) side, and stuck it in the case - against the inside of one of the "wings". This tightnes the fit, and I can still get my m500 in and out ok. Only been a day so far, but working very well. The Velcro only cost me a couple of dollars...well, plus the stuff my wife picked up at the craft store where I got the velcro...so added to the $30 cost of the case, its still not a bad deal.
Does the top of the case stays attached...
Thanks.
RE: Does the top of the case stays attached...
Ed, how does it compare to...
RE: Ed, how does it compare to...
I looked through their old reviews and couldn't find anything recent on molded aluminum cases. Which ones are you talking about?
I received mine today direct from Kensington
being able to touch one. I ordered mine directly from Kensington on Oct 4 and now have it Oct 8 (I
picked Fed Express 2 day shipping).
I also ordered one of the first cases from Innopocket, but that has not arrived yet (ordered Sept 16).
I ordered the USB powered/syncing cable and it took a month so they take a bit long to get product
to you. I believe they are in Hong Kong.
When I get the Innopocket case I'll figure out which one of the 2 I like best for me.
RE: I received mine today direct from Kensington
E-Mail me even! mobilemitch@yahoo.com
RE: I received mine today direct from Kensington
I'm going to get a Kensington as soon as I can find one!
Jefe
RE: I received mine today direct from Kensington
Ed, you're a sick puppy...
--That sounds pornographic--
****ler waz here.
RE: Ed, you're a sick puppy...
Aluminum cases with Belt Clip?
RE: Aluminum cases with Belt Clip?
Review of Rhino vs Kensington.
PDABuzz out of business?
It looks like PDABuzz site is going out of business. The news are fewer and fewer, mostly copied from other sites and there is a lot of incorrect information.
RE: Review of Rhino vs Kensington.
would you venture to be more specific on the incorrect information? I go to that site, and I would like to be sure that I have not been misled on something.
Peace,
bradleyboy
RE: Review of Rhino vs Kensington.
Funny how since I manage every aspect of the site and that any such information would come from me yet oddly enough I don't remember sending that memo or receiving that memo.
I guess this means we're big time since people are taking the time (and wasting the space) to make up garbage about us. I guess f---edcompany.com is next for us, whoo hoo!!
Wes Salmon
PDABuzz.com
RE: Review of Rhino vs Kensington.
> The news are fewer and fewer, mostly copied from other
> sites and there is a lot of incorrect information.
Don't you mean PalmStation? PDABuzz seems to be alive and well while PalmStation gets updated less and less.
RE: Review of Rhino vs Kensington.
- Amin
RE: Review of Rhino vs Kensington.
Peace,
bradleyboy
My Perfect case
RE: My Perfect case
Here's a link to the Neoprene thing I'm using now:
http://makeashorterlink.com/?L2A51531
Latest Comments
- I got one -Tuckermaclain
- RE: Don't we have this already? -Tuckermaclain
- RE: Palm brand will return in 2018, with devices built by TCL -richf
- RE: Palm brand will return in 2018, with devices built by TCL -dmitrygr
- Palm phone on HDblog -palmato
- Palm PVG100 -hgoldner
- RE: Like Deja Vu -PacManFoo
- Like Deja Vu -T_W
Ed Can you put a photo of a palm inside the case.
Does this case has lifetime waranty?